[go: up one dir, main page]

Introducing G2.ai, the future of software buying.Try now
Share your insights with iCIMS

Thousands of people like you come to G2 to find out whether solutions like iCIMS are the right fit for them. Share your real experiences with iCIMS and the G2 community and help someone make the right decision about their software.

iCIMS Pros and Cons: Top Advantages and Disadvantages

Quick AI Summary Based on G2 Reviews

Generated from real user reviews

Users value the ease of use of iCIMS, appreciating its customizable features and excellent support availability. (99 mentions)
Users value the easy customization of iCIMS, enhancing flexibility and simplifying the hiring process significantly. (65 mentions)
Users value the high customizability of iCIMS, enhancing branding and functionality to suit organizational needs. (64 mentions)
Users value the efficiency of iCIMS, simplifying recruitment management and enhancing candidate relationship building. (63 mentions)
Users value the recruitment efficiency of iCIMS, appreciating time savings and streamlined processes for HR tasks. (52 mentions)
Users find the limited customization of iCIMS challenging, requiring extensive configuration and complicated implementation processes. (39 mentions)
Users indicate a steep learning curve due to the complex interface and lengthy implementation process. (38 mentions)
Users find iCIMS not user-friendly, requiring significant time and effort to configure and navigate effectively. (32 mentions)
Users report poor customer support with inconsistent response times and lack of communication during issues. (31 mentions)
Users struggle with difficult navigation in iCIMS, finding it hard to locate settings and requiring significant setup effort. (30 mentions)
Users face missing features in iCIMS, such as outdated products and limits on data export capabilities. (27 mentions)

Top Pros or Advantages of iCIMS

1. Ease of Use
Users value the ease of use of iCIMS, appreciating its customizable features and excellent support availability.
See 99 mentions

See Related User Reviews

SH

Sabra H.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Amazing System with Superior Support"

What do you like about iCIMS?

ICIMS is not only easy to use and integrate, it's completely customizable and flexible to our business needs. My favorite thing about iCIMS is the sup

Cyndi B.
CB

Cyndi B.

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

4.0/5

"iCIMS Talent Cloud review"

What do you like about iCIMS?

We use SkillSurvey exclusively for our reference check process. Very easy to use and very easy to get customer support when needed!

2. Customization
Users value the easy customization of iCIMS, enhancing flexibility and simplifying the hiring process significantly.
See 65 mentions

See Related User Reviews

SH

Sabra H.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Amazing System with Superior Support"

What do you like about iCIMS?

ICIMS is not only easy to use and integrate, it's completely customizable and flexible to our business needs. My favorite thing about iCIMS is the sup

Verified User
A

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.5/5

"Streamlining Recruitment with iCIMS"

What do you like about iCIMS?

It offers a lot of features for streamlining the hiring process. What we like the most is its user-friendly interface, which simplifies the recruitmen

3. Customizability
Users value the high customizability of iCIMS, enhancing branding and functionality to suit organizational needs.
See 64 mentions

See Related User Reviews

AK

Allison K.

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

3.5/5

"Comprehensive Platform"

What do you like about iCIMS?

iCIMS Talent Cloud is a highly customizable ATS and has several integration that were key to our organization. The implementation was a challenge but

Verified User
A

Verified User

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

3.5/5

"Lead capture talent cloud likely to increase engagement/conversion rates of site visitors/candidates"

What do you like about iCIMS?

Customization for branding/appearance; Extensive search filters and sorting; Thorough, detailed reporting features; straightforward UX

4. Efficiency
Users value the efficiency of iCIMS, simplifying recruitment management and enhancing candidate relationship building.
See 63 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
U

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Recruitment Made Easy"

What do you like about iCIMS?

the system makes recruitment organization easy. You can really assess all candidates and the stages that they exist in to provide leadership a better

Cherisse S.
CS

Cherisse S.

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

4.5/5

"Great ATS system!!"

What do you like about iCIMS?

Ability to recruit on a platform that is flexible and easy to use. Helps recruitment stay organized with high volume recruitment and ease of establish

5. Recruitment Efficiency
Users value the recruitment efficiency of iCIMS, appreciating time savings and streamlined processes for HR tasks.
See 52 mentions

See Related User Reviews

KC

Kim C.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Simple, Organized and Scalable"

What do you like about iCIMS?

Given that I have used several CRM, ATS, Talent Systems, etc. over the years, iCIMS Talent Cloud has been better than others with user experience and

Verified User
A

Verified User

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

3.5/5

"Overall the experience with the platform has been good"

What do you like about iCIMS?

The pipeline features. This is a good feature for reviewing future talent

Top Cons or Disadvantages of iCIMS

1. Limited Customization
Users find the limited customization of iCIMS challenging, requiring extensive configuration and complicated implementation processes.
See 39 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
U

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.0/5

"Great Customizable Functionality But Clunky"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

It takes a lot of work upfront to configure the system to your needs and is not simple to implement. We hired an outside consultant to help. There are

Christian H.
CH

Christian H.

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

4.5/5

"User Friendly Talent Platform"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

We are having troubles integrating the interview scheduling, and some minor bugs of collecting info such as emergency contact relationship and being c

2. Learning Curve
Users indicate a steep learning curve due to the complex interface and lengthy implementation process.
See 38 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
U

Verified User

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

3.5/5

"iCIMS Talent Cloud"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Implementation Time: Some users report that the implementation process can be lengthy and complex, requiring a significant time investment.

Verified User
A

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.0/5

"All in one solution"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

The downside to me is the difficult interface. I get lost sometimes with all of the features and have trouble figuring things out without help. It is

3. Not User-Friendly
Users find iCIMS not user-friendly, requiring significant time and effort to configure and navigate effectively.
See 32 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
U

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.0/5

"Great Customizable Functionality But Clunky"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

It takes a lot of work upfront to configure the system to your needs and is not simple to implement. We hired an outside consultant to help. There are

Andra A.
AA

Andra A.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Platform"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

I would like to see more user friendly adjustments made to the Outlook integration and setting up interviews for managers.

4. Poor Customer Support
Users report poor customer support with inconsistent response times and lack of communication during issues.
See 31 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
E

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

2.5/5

"Good Bones, Great Account Team, Bad Support, Late to AI Game"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

The back end support is uneven to terrible. Our dedicated support (TAM) is great, however, the TAMs get shuffled a lot. They do well, get promoted o

KC

Kim C.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Simple, Organized and Scalable"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Although user experience is good, It can be a bit overwhelming with learning. Customer Support response timing was not always good overall. It would a

5. Difficult Navigation
Users struggle with difficult navigation in iCIMS, finding it hard to locate settings and requiring significant setup effort.
See 30 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
U

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.0/5

"Great Customizable Functionality But Clunky"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

It takes a lot of work upfront to configure the system to your needs and is not simple to implement. We hired an outside consultant to help. There are

Verified User
U

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Recruitment Made Easy"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Posting a poisiton should be simplified so that we do not need ot fill in so many steps.

6. Missing Features
Users face missing features in iCIMS, such as outdated products and limits on data export capabilities.
See 27 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Verified User
A

Verified User

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

4.5/5

"9+ Years experience with iCIMS"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

That most communications still have to be delivered by email VS SMS. Additionally, iFORMs are still not optimized for a mobilt environment

KC

Kim C.

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

5.0/5

"Simple, Organized and Scalable"

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Although user experience is good, It can be a bit overwhelming with learning. Customer Support response timing was not always good overall. It would a

iCIMS Reviews (784)

View 1 Video Reviews
Reviews

iCIMS Reviews (784)

View 1 Video Reviews
4.1
784 reviews
Search reviews
View Filters
Filter Reviews
Clear Results
G2 reviews are authentic and verified.
Andrea U.
AU
Talent Acquisition
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Rich in features and integrations, but implementation and ease of use need improvement."
What do you like best about iCIMS?

We are very impressed with the number of features for talent assessment and the excellent ease of integration. The built-in language tests are seamless. For our team, the frequency of use is daily, as we rely on these integrated tools to screen candidates efficiently. Having everything in one platform with a single login truly saves a significant amount of time, just as their customer testimonial suggests. The ability to connect with other assessment providers adds great flexibility. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

The main drawbacks are the overall ease of use and the initial ease of implementation. While powerful, the interface isn't always intuitive, and setting up the various third-party assessment integrations from the marketplace was a complex project. Furthermore, when an issue arises with one of these integrated tools, getting effective customer support can be complicated, as it's not always clear if the problem lies with iCIMS or the third-party provider, leading to delays. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Susan H.
SH
S
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
"iCIMS HR Experience"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

With the elimination of our recruiting department, our HR team has had to step in and quickly learn iCIMS. While the transition hasn’t been easy for all of us, we recognize that iCIMS is a very robust tool. We’re looking forward to building our knowledge so we can fully leverage its capabilities and get the most value out of it. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

I wish the platform were more user-friendly and intuitive. The functionality is there, but the navigation and workflows could be simplified to make the overall user experience smoother and less cumbersome. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

MT
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"iCIMS Talent Cloud Review"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

I have since used the CRM tool within iCIMS. While I'm uncertain my team utilizes it in all the ways it can, I would say that its a nice place to organize and keep things together.

I enjoy the option to text candidates, but I do not use it as a marketing/recruiting tool to blast messages like some might. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

There seem to be more glitches within the past few months. Issues like opening 'notes tab' on a candidate profile create errors and send you back to the home page. I have been in an iform deep in convo with a candidate only to have everything deleted and an error ok. These types of things have been a burden on accomplishing work tasks. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Vicente A.
VA
Talent Acquisition Manager
Facilities Services
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Overcomplicated system"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

Unfortunately later releases have come with major changes that affected production and ongoing glitches. If you need to process high-volume of candidates, this is not the right solution. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Very complex, not very user friendly and slower than other ATS Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Response from Jenine Laviola of iCIMS

Hi Vincente,

My name is Jenine and I am the Customer Marketing Program Manager, here at iCIMS. We're grateful for your feedback regarding the customization and tailoring capabilities of iCIMS Talent Cloud. We understand your concerns about the complexity and speed, and we are committed to making improvements to enhance the user experience. If you want to give any additional feedback please don't hesitate to reach out or contact me directly at Jenine.Laviola@icims.com.

KL
TA Manager
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Moving to Icims has saved us so much time!"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

We find that the flexibility of the reporting has not only helped us to identify gaps in our process, but it’s also helped to improve both the candidate and hiring manager experience. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

At times communicating with tech support can be extremely challenging. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Rebecca E.
RE
Talent Acquisition Specialist
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
"Okay System, Gets the Job Done"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

I like that it is a global system, we are able to have consistency across our company when using it. I am in the system every day and find it easy to use for both an admin perspective as well as a candidate. Implementation was great, we loved our representative, and he got use setup well. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

I do not like their customer service model. I can't ever get a quality or consistent answer when I have trouble. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

MC
Recruiter
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Great product but needs work"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

I love that icims is very configurable. It is easy to build reports and it is easily usable with other systems (UKG) to make recruiting and onboarding processes very seamless. It's a great tool that helps recruiters use data to their advantage and be quicker and better. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

There are some unusual kinks that make icims extremely difficult to work with

- minimum of 10 entrance criteria

- clauses aren't reportable in offer management

- not all fields can populate externally on job board

I also feel like there is a lot of push to an ATS (new icims) that looks aesthetically pleasing but is way less intuitive to use. I feel like there is more emphasis on improving things that don't need to be fixed Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Response from Jenine Laviola of iCIMS

Hello, my name is Jenine Laviola and I am the Customer Marketing Program Manager here at iCIMSThank you for sharing your positive experience with iCIMS and for providing valuable insights on areas for improvement. We are committed to enhancing our platform and will take your feedback into account. If you need anything at all don't hesitate to reach out. Jenine.laviola@icims.com

RA
Senior Manager of TA Operations and Data Analytics
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"A Decade of iCIMS Experience"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

What I like best about iCIMS is the extremely logical setup that the platform has. As a User Admin since 2015, the ability to configure the platform in a company-specific way, based on my own company's logic and how a user's employee OR candidate uses it, is very logical. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

The one thing I dislike about the iCIMS platform is the lack of depth when it comes to using data visualization in-house. Yes, there are programs you can integrate with from another vendor, but sometimes I wish there were better data visualization options within the platform. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

KC
Recruiting and Coordination Team Lead
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Simple, Organized and Scalable"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

Given that I have used several CRM, ATS, Talent Systems, etc. over the years, iCIMS Talent Cloud has been better than others with user experience and like the offerings for the hiring company/customer using it. More recently have been impressed with the ability and customer service of our dedicated account person who is knowledgable and relatable to us. I would certainly make sure to tell others especially compared to other systems which often seem to be payroll systems in disguise versus supporting true recruiting and applicant efforts. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

Although user experience is good, It can be a bit overwhelming with learning. Customer Support response timing was not always good overall. It would also be nice if reporting functions and capabilities were better. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Response from Jenine Laviola of iCIMS

Hello my name is Jenine Laviola and I am the Customer Marketing Program Manager here at iCIMS. It's great to hear that iCIMS Talent Cloud is helping you organize applicants and candidates more effectively. We are focused on providing tools that save time and streamline the recruiting process. Your feedback about the learning curve and reporting capabilities is valuable and will be taken into consideration for future enhancements. If you need anything at all please don't hesitate to reach out Jenine.Laviola@icims.com

JS
HR Manager - Operations
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
"Highly Customizable and Adaptable to Unique Workflows"
What do you like best about iCIMS?

My experience with the platform is that 99% of the applications are highly customizeable and adaptable to unique workflows or a varying workflows within the same organization. We are a global organization and we are integrated with Workday for our HRIS. Each region seems to have variations in their workflows for what candidate information is required upon application and upon hire and with iCIMS we are quickly able to adapt and make changes to the system by configuring custom fields, iforms, and reporting. Our dedicated account manager provides us amazing insights on best practices and is always available for discussions when we're stuck or need assistance! Reporting features are robust and allow you to get at metrics we never thought possible and see them at a glance! Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about iCIMS?

We currently are using CRM, not CXM, which does leave a little to be desired when it comes to reporting usage statistics for our TA team, but our account manager has passed along our concerns and support has been willing to work with us to create some customizations and make updates to the application which have been helpful to improving our process. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Response from Jenine Laviola of iCIMS

Hello my name is Jenine and I am the Customer Marketing Program Managere here at iCIMS. We're pleased to hear that iCIMS has helped you report on key metrics regularly and streamline your hiring process through integrations and customizable workflows. Your feedback about the CRM (and not using CXM) usage statistics is important to us, and we are working on solutions to address this concern. We appreciate your support and look forward to continuing to provide value to your organization. If you need anything at all don't hesitate to reach out Jenine.Laviola@icims.com

Product Avatar Image
Product Avatar Image